DEAR SCOTT HENDERSON

   Last week I got to view the movie “Dear Evan Hansen” with my daughter Abbie who had been looking forward to seeing it.  Scott - May 18, 2021Unfortunately the movie did not live up to her expectations.  She and her sister Emily were in New York a few years ago when “Dear Evan Hansen” was playing on Broadway but they couldn’t get tickets.  Abbie has been listening to the Broadway soundtrack for a few years and had high expectations for the movie.  Critical reviews of the movie were not stellar and Abbie and I were also left disappointed in the film. 

   If you haven’t seen the film, you should.  It’s the story of an awkward teenager who writes letters to himself for self-affirmation.  Unfortunately one of the letters is intercepted by another teen who kills himself.  The letter, found in the dead teen’s possessions, suggests that the late teen and Evan Hansen had a friendship which was shared through letters and emails.  The story goes on to be inspirational through the songs and the bond Evan creates with the dead teen’s family and Evan’s classmates who struggle to make sense of things.  It’s an interesting story and worth a viewing even if we thought it didn’t really come together. The Greatest Showman Abbie said that some of the Broadway songs were not included in the film and others were added.  Music and lyrics were created by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul who also worked on “The Greatest Showman.”  “The Greatest Showman” is a much better film and has wonderful songs. 

   I started thinking about the idea of someone writing to themselves for affirmation.  I remembered that I once wrote a poem back in 1986 to myself.  The title was “to old one” and it was about wanting to ask my elder self how I got through things or if I’d be okay in the future.  Here’s that poem: 

to old one

I imagine one day
I’ll be old–
and knowin’ me
one day will be about
all I can hack–
so I’m writin’ this to my old self
not what I was
but what I’ll be
for that one day

I’m tellin’ myself
to be happy
bein’ old
’cause maybe by then
I’ll have deserved that
but now I can’t accord dignity
in addressin’ my old self
and this’ll only make sense
later on
to an old man

but old one,
that’s you or I mean me,
yer ruptured youth
is writin’ to you here
’cause we’re two different persons
you and me
and you know things
I’ve yet to live
but that’s cause
yer memory and you
are old old one

and there was a time
when I needed you
to talk to me
and tell me
how I got by things or
over ’em or
through ’em
but that’d be cheatin’
and I matured into that truth

but old one
young one
still needs you
’cause I need to know
I’m still gonna be me
but old me
and someone new to talk to
if only in my mind
when we’re one

so know yer youth
old one
and keep in touch
or get in touch
with this
young one
who needs not to know
you’re old old one
but old enough to remember being
young once
and writing to
yer old self
to hear if
you stayed
old
long enough
to receive this poem
written by
yer young one once

I wouldn’t say it’s one of my better efforts but it was what I was feeling and the way I was writing at the time.  I’m sure there’s not a song to be made of it.  If I had to reply to my young self I’d say “no comment” or “spoiler alert” because it would be cheating to help my young self out.  I had problems and adversity but it made me who I am today and if I told myself to avoid all of those things then I’d be completely different and the truth is I’m fine being me. 

   I started reading through all of my poems around that time and found that some were good and some were bad but the bulk were mediocre and not worth repeating.  I did find another poem written in December of 1986 that I thought I would post here along the line of Dear…  Here’s “dear santa”: 

dear santa

I was maybe nine
when my parents
up and told me
there’s no Santa Claus
and I suspected
at the time
that they weren’t
bein’ truthful ’bout that

but now
I’m pretty sure
they were mistaken
’cause I saw old Nick
the other day
at the mall
and I can’t help wonderin’
if he knows
parents are tryin’
to suppress
his existence
all over

and why is that?
what have parents got
against Santa?

ya know it just might be
that Nick’s too powerful
for the average parent
’cause all year long
moms and dads
try to discipline
their kids
without success
but ya mention
Santa
anywhere nears Christmas
and control is
immediately established

and maybe that’s it!
maybe parents
get their ego’s bruised
by the idea
of some
white beard old goat
havin’ more pull
than them

and maybe that’s why
after eight or nine years
the kids are told
this lie
about St. Nicholas
bein’ a myth
so’s parents can say
“LISTEN UP,
WE’RE THE BOSS.
THERE’S NO SANTA
JUST US
AND YOU EITHER
LIKE IT
OR LUMP IT”

but I’m not sayin’
I disagree with
this method
’cause at some point
ya gotta outgrow
the need for Santa Claus

ya gotta depend
on the family
and what they can do
fer ya
and ya’ll be
a better person-
-more rounded
not in the gut
like Santa
but in your outlook

sure the method’s okay
but what if
ya reversed the order
and said right off-
right at birth-
“KID YOU’RE GONNA HEAR A LOT
ABOUT THIS
SANTA CLAUS
BUT DON’T BELIEVE IT.
WE’RE THE ONES
YOU HAVE TO RESPECT.
WE’RE THE ONES
WHO ARE
LOOKING OUT FOR YOU.”

and maybe later
when the kids are older
and have lost
all faith
in mankind
and have given up
on anything magical
ya sent them straight
’bout Nick

ya tell ’em
ya lied
and there really is
this St. Nicholas guy
and he’s alright
and as long as
they believe in him
they’ll be alright too

and wouldn’t it be easier
that way?
wouldn’t it be nicer
to know
ya haven’t ruined
yer kid’s entire life?

sure tell ’em ’bout Santa
and they’ll pass the word
and they’ll believe
and behave
and ya’ll have
no more problems
in discipline
if ya use Nick’s name

‘cept maybe ’round Easter
when his moniker
brings no pull
whatsoever…

  Maybe there’s a song somewhere in that or maybe I’m thinking of the 1993 song “Hey Santa” by Wendy and Carnie Wilson :

By the way, in case Santa is reading this then “World Peace” is still at the top of my Christmas wish list.  If you can’t bring me that, Santa, then a personalized letter starting “Dear Scott Henderson” would be great too.  Then I could pass it among my little friends, and say “see, I told you Santa is real.”

Comments are closed.